The Easy Explanation: Sam Leavitt and the Tradition That Wasn’t

A quarterback walked off the field and the internet knew exactly what it meant. The explanation arrived before anyone checked whether the thing had happened.
On the night of November 14, Texas beat LSU 22-21 in Tiger Stadium on a touchdown with seconds left, the first Texas win in Baton Rouge in seventy-four years. It was Senior Night. Sam Leavitt, LSU’s quarterback, had thrown three interceptions. When the game ended he walked off toward the tunnel.
Within a day that walk had become a referendum on college athletics.
Clips went up showing that Leavitt had left before the alma mater. Tyrann Mathieu, who played at LSU and knows what that stadium asks of people, said on his podcast that ten years ago college was about culture and community, and that "you don’t get that vibe no more." He tied it to the portal. "A lot of kids, they don’t grow up reading books about tradition. If they did, it wouldn’t be 900,002 transfer guys every year." Others piled on with some version of the same idea. Money can buy you a roster but it cannot buy loyalty. This is what you get when players are paid. This is the new era, and here is your proof.
The story was clean, and it fit everything we have been told about where the sport is going.
Then the detail came out. LSU players do not stay on the field for the alma mater after losses. They have not done so since 2005, when Les Miles arrived. Michael Bonnette, the school’s associate athletic director, said it plainly: the team stays for the song after wins. Asked whether players had ever been required to stay after a loss, he said, "We never have." Lane Kiffin, in his first season at LSU after leaving Ole Miss, said he had asked Bonnette that same question following an earlier loss and gotten the same answer. The widely shared detail about a teammate pulling Leavitt out of the locker room to come back for the song did not happen either.
Leavitt did what that roster has done after every loss for twenty years.
Let me be clear about what I am not arguing. I am not defending how he played. Kiffin was not defending it, either. His words were that you should get criticized when you throw the ball to the other team three times and do not play well in the fourth quarter, and that is correct. A quarterback at LSU signed up for that. I am also not arguing that nothing has changed in college athletics, because a great deal has changed, and I will get to that.
What I am interested in is the speed.
People are wrong on the internet every day and it is not usually worth a column. What makes this one worth your attention is that the explanation arrived before anyone looked. Nobody called the sports information office. Nobody asked a player from 2015 what the team did after a loss. The story was available, it fit, and that was enough.
Three days later a reporter asked Leavitt about it directly. His answer was, "Oh yeah, I don’t even know what you’re referring to, like staying and singing the song after, you’re saying?" Then, "I don’t know what anyone’s really saying, to be honest. I’m not even on any socials."
Read that through one lens and it is a young man who has checked out, who cannot be troubled to learn what his own stadium expects of him. Read it through the other and it is a young man honestly baffled by a controversy over a tradition that was never there, which is exactly what the people who run the building had already said. The words are identical either way. What decides the reading is what you believed before it happened.
That is what a default explanation does. It is the answer you reach for before you examine what’s in front of you, and in college athletics right now the default explanation is that everything is transactional. The portal did it, the money did it, and kids today are not what they were.
For a fan, a default explanation doesn’t cost anything. For a coach, it can cost the program.
Here is how it does the damage. An explanation that covers everything in advance removes the reason to build anything. If the problem is the era, then the thin effort in the fourth quarter is the era, and the player who will not look you in the eye is the era, and the locker room that went quiet in October is the era. Every one of those has an external cause and none of them is yours to fix. You can run an entire season on that and never once have to look at your own program.
So concede the ground that deserves conceding. There is more transaction in big-time college athletics than there was five years ago, and pretending otherwise is its own kind of denial. Spending money does not guarantee success, and not spending money will prevent it. None of that is in dispute.
All of that is about acquisition, though, and the question underneath it is the one that matters most: what happens after the player you recruited is standing in your building.
That is the decision in front of coaches right now, and it is a decision rather than a condition. You can throw up your hands and go all in on the transactional reading, which has the advantage of being easy and the disadvantage of being the end of your program as anything but a payroll. Or you can double down on the culture by doing four unglamorous things: define it, enforce it, recruit the players who fit it, and tell them exactly what it is the day they arrive.
Then hold them to it for as long as they are with you, whether that turns out to be one season or five.
That costs something in the short term. You will turn some players off. Some will not stay past a year. There will be a recruiting weekend where you watch a talented kid decide you are too much work.
Over a longer horizon it pays, because the word gets out. People come to understand what kind of program you run, and the right talent, meaning the talent that fits what you are building, starts moving toward you instead of away. You can name the programs in football and basketball that have this. They are not quiet about who they are, and they are not confused about who they want.
The worst available option is neither of the two. It is to say you are one thing and then be another. To talk about academics and culture and campus life in the living room, and then to hold nobody to any of it once the signing is done. That does not buy you the flexibility it seems to promise. It costs you the one thing a program cannot operate without, which is people knowing what you are.
A player who leaves because your standard was too high is a player you were never going to keep. A player who stays because there was no standard at all is a problem you created.
Which brings me back to a quarterback walking off a field in Baton Rouge, doing exactly what his program had always done, while a few thousand people who had never checked explained to each other what it said about the state of the sport.
The sport has real problems. That was not one of them. And the reflex to see one anyway, before looking, is worth more of your attention than the walk ever was. Because the same reflex, applied inside your own building, will tell you that the thing going wrong down the hall is because of the era rather than the culture. It will be wrong about that too.




Comments