top of page
Horiz Lockup on White.png

Deshaun Watson, Justin Tucker, and the Decisions to Sign Them

Nov 6
6 min read
Football player Deshaun Watson walks across a field wearing an orange football uniform and carrying his water bottle and helmet.
Erik Drost, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Two organizations explained their choices this fall. Neither explanation was about values, and that is the part worth a conversation in your own program.


Sunday in Pittsburgh was ugly in the way that makes a fan turn the television down and keep watching anyway. I watched all of it.


That loss sits inside a season no one saw coming. Cleveland is 5-3, better than anyone predicted in August, and I have enjoyed it more than I expected to. The quarterback is Deshaun Watson, who arrived in Cleveland in 2022 under public accusations of sexual misconduct.


I grew up in Northeast Ohio. I have been a Browns fan for more than half a century, through decades that handed a reasonable person every excuse to quit, and I didn't. I'm proud of that. I'm not leaving now that they're winning, just like I didn't leave when they went 1-31 across two seasons.


This is not a piece about whether I am going to stop watching, because I'm not. It's about a question I can't get around while I keep watching. The question is not whether Deshaun Watson deserves anything. I'm not in a position to answer that, and neither are most. The question is what the organization decided, how it decided, and when it decided.


The argument I am going to make is this. A decision about a player with a public problem is only a values decision if the values were settled before the name came up. Cleveland explained itself at length in 2022, and Kansas City explained itself last week, and neither explanation named a standard. One pointed at its diligence. The other pointed at a suspension being over. Both describe a process, and a process is not a decision.


Go back to March of 2022, when Cleveland traded three first round picks for Watson and signed him to a fully guaranteed contract worth 230 million dollars. The accusations were public. Everyone involved understood what the decision would look like. So the organization explained itself, at length, through four people.


The statement from Dee and Jimmy Haslam said the team's "comprehensive evaluation process was of utmost importance due to the sensitive nature of his situation." Jimmy Haslam told reporters they had "put more time, more thought, more effort, talked to more people and did more research on this decision by far." Andrew Berry, the general manager, said the club had done "extensive investigative, legal and reference work over the past several months." Kevin Stefanski, then the head coach, said the organization "did a tremendous amount of background on Deshaun."


Four men, four ways of saying the same thing, which is that they looked very hard. Notice what is missing. Not one of them said what they were looking for. No one named a thing that, had they found it, would have ended the conversation. The thoroughness was the entire defense.


What all that looking produced was not a standard, and it was not a verdict either. Nobody from the club ever said what they had concluded about the accusations. What they offered instead was how they felt about him. Jimmy Haslam said they "got very comfortable with Deshaun Watson the person." The joint statement called him "humble, sincere, and candid." Berry said, "We feel very confident in Deshaun the person." Those are sentences about the people speaking, not findings about the man they were speaking about or the values that were used to make that judgment.


There is one more piece of the record, and it deserves careful handling. Haslam also said the club "got strong recommendation from legal counsel for us not to reach out to the 22 women," and Berry said the same. That is ordinary legal advice while litigation is live, and I'm not going to assume it's sinister. It does mean that a comprehensive evaluation, by the organization's own account, could not include the accounts at the center of the matter, and a confident public finding about the man's character was announced anyway.


The rest of the record is straightforward. Watson was suspended for eleven games in 2022, the civil suits were settled, and two Texas grand juries declined to bring charges. I'm not here to adjudicate what did or did not happen, and no part of this piece depends on it.


Five months after the trade, Haslam was asked why Watson deserved another chance, and his answer began where you would expect. "Is he never supposed to play again? Is he never supposed to be a part of society? Does he get no chance to rehabilitate himself? That's what we're gonna do." Those are fair questions and I don't dismiss them. Then he said the rest of it himself.


"You can say that's because he's a star quarterback. Well, of course."


That is the whole thing, from the man who made the decision. The chance was available because of what the player could do on Sunday. I don't have to argue the point, because the owner conceded it.


Kansas City answered the same kind of question last week, differently. The Chiefs signed Justin Tucker to their practice squad after he served a ten-game suspension over sexual misconduct allegations, and Andy Reid explained the move in five words. "He's done his suspension."


That is a cleaner sentence than Cleveland managed, and it fails in the same way. The league's punishment ended, therefore the matter is closed. It describes a process reaching its conclusion. It does not describe one thing the organization believes.

I want to be careful about something. Every organization has the right to decide this for itself. A program sits inside a city, a conference, a fan base, and a particular moment, and the threshold that is right for one is not automatically right for another. I'm not arguing that every team should have passed on Watson. I'm also not arguing that nobody should ever get a second chance, having needed more than one myself.


What I am arguing is narrower and harder than that. A program with a real standard can sign him or pass on him and defend either decision in public, because the decision was measured against something the program had already settled. A program without one is doing talent math and calling it judgment afterward. From the outside those two look identical, right up until somebody asks where the line was between sign him or pass.

Chances are, most of us will never have to decide on a Deshaun Watson. Every one of you, however, will decide on a transfer with something in his history, an assistant who crossed a line, or a kid who did something ugly in the spring and happens to be the best player you have. The decision never arrives as a philosophy question. It arrives attached to a name, a face, and a known talent level, which is the worst possible moment to go looking for a line you never drew. Talent and usefulness distort our judgment the same way.


Think of the last time you kept or took someone with a known problem. The real one, the one you were already thinking of. Then write down, in a single sentence, the reason you gave at the time, in the words you said out loud to your staff.


I suspect it will look like one of two sentences, either that he gives us the best chance to win, or that he served his punishment and it is behind him. Both are things decent people say in good faith. Neither one is a standard.


Then do the part that is harder than the audit. Decide the line now, while nothing is riding on it, and say it out loud to one other person so that it exists somewhere outside your own head. A standard you've never spoken isn't a standard. It is a preference you reserve the right to revise when the player is good enough.


In March of last year, three years after the trade, Jimmy Haslam finally said what he thought of it. "We took a big swing and miss with Deshaun. We thought we had the quarterback, we didn't."


The regret, when it finally arrived, was about the quarterback's performance. Not one word about anything else. Whatever that organization was measuring in 2022, it was still measuring the same thing in 2025, and the only thing that had changed was the answer it got.


I will be in front of the television on Sunday, of course. The Browns are 5-3, and I hope they'll be 6-3 by Monday. I still haven't worked out whether rooting for a team is the same as endorsing what it decided, and perhaps it's not that deep. Ask me again in January.


Comments


bottom of page